Enjoy the creamy texture and the mild, unique flavor! Troyer Colby Cheese is made without any milk powders and without blending the whey cream back into the cheese milk. Maintaining these stringent standards keeps the texture of our Colby creamy and gives it the unique Colby taste that many people love. The traditional, mellow color is from Annatto, a natural colorant and spice that's added to the pasteurized cultured milk. Contains Milk.