Free shipping with orders over $50

Cheese

To maintain freshness, all cheese orders may be held a few days. If the order is not deliverable by Friday, it will ship the following Monday. All perishable items require a insulated cooler and ice packs.

$4.99
Great Shelf Life.Body and Texture: Creamy, smooth and spreadable, with slight grainy texture This Troyer Aged Asiago cheese spread is designated as Cold...
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
Salemville Amish Blue Cheese: Salemvilles award-winning blue-veined cheeses are sustainably produced by and hand-crafted by Amish Artisans. Amish Blue...
+

Minimum quantity for "Amish Blue Cheese 4oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$14.99
Guggisberg Baby Swiss Cheese Whole Wheels 2 lb: A delicious semi-soft cheese with a buttery, subtly sweet flavor, Guggisberg Baby Swiss Cheese is the...
+

Minimum quantity for "Baby Swiss Whole Wheels 2lb" is 1.

Add to wish list

$26.99
Guggisberg Baby Swiss Cheese Whole Wheels 4 lb: A delicious semi-soft cheese with a buttery, subtly sweet flavor, Guggisberg Baby Swiss Cheese is the...
+

Minimum quantity for "Baby Swiss Whole Wheels 4lb" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.49
+
Add to wish list

$6.49
Ingredients: Pasteurized Part-Skim Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Cheese Cultures, Jalapeno Peppers. CONTAINS: MILK
+
Add to wish list

$6.49
Ingredients: Milk, Cheese Cultures, Enzymes, Salt, Annatto (if colored). CONTAINS: MILK
+
Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Black Wax Hoop Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. Contains Milk. Black Wax Hoop Cheddar 10oz...
+

Minimum quantity for "Black Wax Hoop Cheddar Cheese10oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.49
Troyer Blue Marble Natural Cheese Mini Loaves consists of a creamy, semi-soft cheese with a Monterey Jack texture, beautifully marbled with blue veins woven...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Blueberry Cheddar Cheese is mixed with blueberries for a sweet finish. It is a part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. Contains Milk....
+

Minimum quantity for "Blueberry Cheddar Cheese10oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$5.99
Combining the flavors of tomatoes, garlic, basil and parsley to create a fantastic flavor, known as Bruschetta Jack cheese. Imagine macaroni and cheese made...
+
Add to wish list

$6.49
Troyer Buffalo Wing Natural Cheese Mini Loaves are not made in Buffalo, New York, but you might think they were. The savory, spicy and tangy Buffalo Wing...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Buffalo Wing Cheddar Cheese Curds are made with only the best ingredients. You will notice a springy texture with the same firmness and density as...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Cajun Cheddar Cheese Curds are made with only the best ingredients. You will notice a springy texture with the same firmness and density as cheese...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Rich and creamy cheddar blended with Carolina Reaper Chili Peppers. Tasting Troyer's Carolina Reaper Cheddar is an EVENT...it will be a journey that your...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Black Creek® Cheddar Cheese with Gruyère Notes is a masterful blend of robust Cheddar paired with a hint of nutty, earthy and piquant Gruyère flavors. The...
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
Troyer Chipolte Pepper Cheese is a combination of American cheese, Natural Monterey Pepper Jack cheese, chipotle peppers for a wonderful 'kick'. Contains...
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
Enjoy the creamy texture and the mild, unique flavor! Troyer Colby Cheese is made without any milk powders and without blending the whey cream back into the...
+

Minimum quantity for "Colby Cheese (15oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$30.99
What does a 'desert fire' taste like?  Taste Troyer's Desert Fire Chunked cheese, with its jalapeno peppers, to find out. Desert Fire Cheese (5lb)...
+

Minimum quantity for "Desert Fire Cheese (5lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$5.99
What does a 'desert fire' taste like?  Taste Troyer's Desert Fire Chunked cheese, with its jalapeno peppers, to find out.  Contains Milk. Desert Fire...
+

Minimum quantity for "Desert Fire Cheese (9.5oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Garlic/Dill Cheddar Cheese Curds are made with only the best ingredients. You will notice a springy texture with the same firmness and density as...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Farmers Cheese is mild, sweet, and nutty! Great on crackers, or with grapes, apples, berries. Farmers Cheese is often used for fillings in blintzes...
+

Minimum quantity for "Farmers Cheese (1lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Garlic Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. It makes a really great mornay sauce for pasta. Contains Milk....
+

Minimum quantity for "Garlic Cheddar Cheese (8oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.49
Troyer Ghost Pepper Cheese Prepack - rBST Free Appearance/Color: White to Light Beige with Red/Orange Flakes Flavor/Odor: Mild Cheese-Pungent Hot Chile...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Ghost Pepper Cheddar Cheese Curds are made with only the best ingredients. You will notice a springy texture with the same firmness and density as...
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
Absolutely amazing on crackers and cold slider sandwiches! Troyer Green Onion Cheese will 'WOW!' your taste buds. Green Onion Cheese (1lb) Natural...
+
Add to wish list

$4.49
FLAVOR: Mild Cheddar taste, with onion flavor, no off flavors.TEXTURE:Firm, Shreddable, Good Melt, Sliceable. COLOR:White with green flakes. REFRIGERATE...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Experience the premium taste of our imported Gruyere cheese. Its creamy, smooth flavor melts in your mouth. Made with pure, fresh milk from family-owned...
+
Add to wish list

$41.99
Troyer Gueten Sharp Habenaro Cheddar Cheese There are many cheddar cheeses on the market that claim to be sharp or extra sharp, but taste no sharper than a...
+
Add to wish list

$8.99
Troyer Gueten Sharp Habenaro Jalapeno Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. - Contains Milk. Gueten Sharp...
+

Minimum quantity for "Habanero Jalapeno Cheese (10oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Buffalo Wing Cheddar Cheese Curds are made with only the best ingredients. You will notice a springy texture with the same firmness and density as...
+
Add to wish list

$4.49
Calling all horseradish fans...FLAVOR: Mild Cheddar taste, with horseradish flavor, no off flavors. TEXTURE:Firm, Shreddable, Good Melt, Sliceable.COLOR:...
+
Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Horseradish Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. A blend of aged cheddar and fresh ground horseradish. Bold...
+

Minimum quantity for "Horseradish Cheddar Cheese (8oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.99
Troyer Horseradish Cheese Spread is a delicious and satisfying rich blend of horseradish and cheese. Horseradish Flavor Cheese Spread 8oz...
+

Minimum quantity for "Horseradish Flavor Cheese Spread 8oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$30.99
Troyer Hot Pepper Cheese has just the right amount of heat to make it a perfect Hot Pepper Cheese! You have to try it to believe it. Hot Pepper...
+

Minimum quantity for "Hot Pepper Cheese (5lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.49
Red and green jalapenos provide the mild zing to this hot pepper cheese. FLAVOR: Mild Cheddar taste, with jalapeno pepper flavor, no off flavors. TEXTURE:...
+
Add to wish list

$4.99
Great Shelf Life.This Troyer Jalapeno cheese spread is designated as Cold Pack, which signifies that it is made without the aid of heat. As such, it remains...
+

Minimum quantity for "Jalapeno Cheese Spread 8oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$5.99
Both red and green peppers bring exceptional taste and color to Troyer Lightning Jack Cheese. Contains Milk. Lightning Jack Cheese (1lb)...
+

Minimum quantity for "Lightning Jack Cheese (1lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$7.99
Limburger, first introduced in Belgium, is the most famous of all Belgian cheeses. Country Castle is the only cheese factory in the United States still...
+
Add to wish list

$8.99
Two words: SWEET and SPICY! Troyer Mango Fire Cheddar is a mild to medium creamy white cheddar blended with mango and habanero. Perfect with grain crackers...
+

Minimum quantity for "Mango Fire Cheddar Cheese (10oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$5.99
Troyer Marble Cheese is made the old fashioned way. Instead of just using white and colored Colby cheese , we use white Monterrey Jack and colored Colby...
+

Minimum quantity for "Marble Cheese (1lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.79
This classic Mascarpone is a naturally sweet, yet surprisingly light cheese (1/2 the calories of butter) produced from only the freshest cream. Its soft,...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Mild Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. Contains Milk. Mild Cheddar (15oz) Ingredients:...
+

Minimum quantity for "Mild Cheddar (15oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.49
Mild Garlic Cheddar - Just the right amount of garlic! FLAVOR: Mild Cheddar taste, with garlic flavor, no off flavors. TEXTURE: Firm, Shreddable, Good Melt,...
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
The orange rind makes it a perfect addition to your next party tray. Troyer Muenster cheese is creamy, soft, mild in flavor, and makes a great appetizer....
+

Minimum quantity for "Muenster Cheese (1lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Delicious, Troyer Swiss Cheese goes with just about everything. Contains Milk. Natural Swiss Cheese (1lb) Ingredients: Milk, cultures, rennet, salt....
+

Minimum quantity for "Natural Swiss Cheese (1lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.99
+
Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Pepper Jack Cheese features red and green peppers for exceptional taste and color. Contains Milk. Pepper Jack Cheese (15oz) Ingredients:...
+

Minimum quantity for "Pepper Jack Cheese (15oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Pepperoni Cheese is a combination of pepperoni and american cheese. Pepperoni Cheese (9.5oz) Ingredients: American cheese (cultured milk,...
+

Minimum quantity for "Pepperoni Cheese (9.5oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
+
Add to wish list

$4.99
Pimento Cheese Spread 7oz Ingredients: pasturized cream cheese (milk and cream, cultures, salt, carob bean gum), cheddar cheese (made from...
+

Minimum quantity for "Pimento Cheese Spread 7oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Ingredients: Pasteurized milk, cheese culture, salt, enzymes, dried buttermilk, onion, garlic, hydrolized cornprotein, lactic acid calcium lactate,...
+
Add to wish list

$7.49
Troyer Red Wax Hoop Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. Contains Milk. Red Wax Hoop Cheddar (10oz)...
+

Minimum quantity for "Red Wax Hoop Cheddar Cheese (10oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$5.99
Ingredients: American Cheese ( Pasteurized Cultered Milk, salt, Enzymes), Salami (Pork, Beef, Salt, Sugar,Lactic Acid Starter Culture, Flavorings, Sodium...
+
Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Scorpion Cheddar Natural Cheese - rBST Free Appearance/Color Golden with blend of red pepper Flavor/Odor Rich & Creamy with hint of Chile Pepper,...
+
Add to wish list

$4.99
This Troyer Sharp Cheddar cheese spread is designated as Cold Pack, which signifies that it is made without the aid of heat. As such, it remains as similar...
+

Minimum quantity for "Sharp Cheddar Cheese Spread 8oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Simply Meltz Easy Ingredients: AMERICAN CHEESE (MILK, CHEESE CULTURE, SALT, ENZYMES), WATER, NONFAT DRY MILK, WHEY, SODIUMPHOSPHATES, MILKFAT, SALT,...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Smoked Baby Swiss Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Baby Swiss Cheese (8oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$14.99
Troyer Smoked Cheddar Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Cheddar Cheese (2.25lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Smoked Cheddar Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Cheddar Cheese (8oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.99
Ingredients: Cheese(Swiss, Cheddar, Colby(Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto)), Water, Skim Milk, Sodium Phosphate, Whey, Salt, Liquid Smoke,...
+
Add to wish list

$4.49
A flavor jackpot! Smoked flavor plus the taste of sharp cheddar.FLAVOR:Smoked Sharp Cheddar taste, no off flavors. TEXTURE: Firm, Shreddable, No Melt,...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Smoked Green Onion Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+
Add to wish list

$15.99
Troyer Smoked Green Onion Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Green Onion Cheese (2.25lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$8.99
Troyer Smoked Habenaro Cheddar Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Habanero Jalapeno (10oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Smoked Horseradish American Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Horseradish Bar (10oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$15.99
Troyer Smoked Horseradish American Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+
Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Smoked Horseradish Cheddar features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Horseradish Cheddar (10oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$15.99
Ingredients: american cheese (cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes), water, whey, jalapeno peppers, sodiumphosphate, red bell peppers, salt, oleoresin...
+
Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Smoked Hot Pepper Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Hot Pepper Cheese (8oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Smoked Mozzarella Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Mozzarella Cheese (1lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Smoked Natural Swiss Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Natural Swiss Cheese (10oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Smoked Provolone Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Provolone Cheese (1lb)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Smoked Swiss Cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor. This smoked cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoked Swiss Cheese (8oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.99
Troyer Bacon Cheese Spread is a delicious and satisfying rich blend of bacon and cheese. This Troyer Smokey Bacon Flavor cheese spread is designated as...
+

Minimum quantity for "Smoky Bacon Flavor Cheese Spread 8oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$5.99
For a quick, delicious snack, try TroyerÕs all-natural Mozzarella String Cheese. This family pack features 12 individually wrapped 1 oz snacks. It is...
+

Minimum quantity for "Troyer String Cheese 12oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.49
When sharp cheddar is not enough...FLAVOR Very Sharp Cheddar taste, no off flavors. TEXTURE: Firm, Shreddable, Good Melt, Sliceable. COLOR: Colored....
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer White Cheddar Cheese Curds are made with only the best ingredients. You will notice a springy texture with same firmness and density as cheese....
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
Troyer White Sharp Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. There are many cheddar cheeses on the market that claim to...
+

Minimum quantity for "White Sharp Cheddar Cheese (8oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$4.99
Our award winning cheese is hickory smoked with a creamy texture. Ingredients: Cheese(Swiss, Cheddar, Colby(Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes)),...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Yellow Cheddar Cheese Curds are made with only the best ingredients. You will notice a springy texture with the same firmness and density as cheese...
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
Troyer Yellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. Contains Milk. Yellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese (8oz)...
+

Minimum quantity for "Yellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese (8oz)" is 1.

Add to wish list

$7.99
Troyer Yellow X-Sharp Cheddar Cheese is part of Troyer's award-winning blue-ribbon, "A-Grade" cheese. There are many cheddar cheeses on the market that claim...
+

Minimum quantity for "Yellow X Sharp Cheddar 8oz" is 1.

Add to wish list

$6.99
Troyer Yellow/White Mixed Cheddar Cheese Curds are made with only the best ingredients. You will notice a springy texture with the same firmness and density...
+
Add to wish list